HOW TO SELECT WHICH KNIFE STEEL TO USE
Important information regarding how to select knife steel grade depending on your grinding wheel, and other characteristics.

KNIFE STEEL

HOW TO SELECT WHICH STEEL TO USE

One key thing to remember is that whenever you change knife steel grade, it is very likely that you will have to change the grinding wheel being used. In some cases, changing the speed of the grinding wheel will still produce a high quality knife.

Knife steel is available in many grades. The correct use of each steel is related to its grade and characteristics. The most important characteristics to be concerned with include:

  • Flatness - Bowed steel is a good indication of problems in the manufacturing process, normally in the heat treating of the steel. This can cause major problems with maintaining proper balance of the steel.

  • Corrugation Alignment- The trueness of the corrugation is critical. Verify that the steel has its bottom corrugation true along the entire length of the knife bar. In the past, some manufacturers have supplied knife steel that would gain a complete corrugation over the 25 inch length of a standard bar. This causes severe balance problems and makes it impossible to grind accurate knives.

  • Corrugation design- After many years of using different knife steels, it has been proven that the corrugations should not come to a perfect point. All corrugations should have a slight flat on their top. This will insure that the knife is held tightly in place against the sides of the corrugations. If the knife has an exact point on it, it requires that the head body also have an exact point and that no contamination is present in the head body.

  • Heat treating- The method used for heat treating is one of the most critical processes in the manufacture of knife steel. There are many types of heat treating processes. What is most important to the end user is the consistency of this process. Every bar of knife steel must be the same. If you are using a knife steel that grinds different each time a new bar is used then the heat treating of the stock may be a concern. Improper heat treating will create hard and soft spots in the knife material and this makes it almost impossible to produce quality knives.

  • Availability- No knife steel will work if you can not get it when you need it.

  • Cost effectiveness- This does not mean that the cheapest is the best. Factors such as grind time and run time on the machine must be considered when deciding on a knife steel program.

- back

 

SAFETY OF THE STEEL AND ITS USE

MAXIMUM DEPTH OF PROFILE

It is important to use the correct knife thickness for the application that the tool is being prepared for. Most knife steels are available in 1/4”, 5/16” and 3/8” thicknesses. The depth of cut should never exceed 3 times the thickness of the tool.
 

If you are using 1/4” steel this means that no more than 3/4” of steel should be ground into the profile. When using 5/16” this goes up to 15/16” and with 3/8” steel the maximum depth is 1-1/8”.

 

MAXIMUM KNIFE PROJECTION 

No matter what type of knife stock you are using, never exceed the safe limit of the knife when installing it into the head body. Most head bodies use the base of the gib as the limiting point of knife projection. Never extend the knives out past where the gib screw is pressing against the full corrugation of the knife. This can damage the head and release the knives.

MACHINE RPM

It is necessary to check the rpm of the tool being used to the rpm of the machine that tool is being run on. Some tools are rated at 6,000 rpm, while others are rated at 9,000 rpm. Check to make sure the tool will work on your machine. The tool must also be dynamically balanced to your RPM.

- back

 

KNIFE STEEL CORRUGATIONS

Unless otherwise stated, all corrugated knife steel will be 16-60. This means that the corrugations are 1/16” apart and have a 60 degree angle on them. It is not recommended to substitute 16-90, (1/16 between corrugations with a 90 degree angle of the corrugation) corrugated steel for 16-60 or visa versa. Use the correct style for the heads you are using. Be sure to properly install and secure the knives in your cutterheads.

Select your knife steel carefully. Consider what the profile will be used for and how often the profile will be reused. This will help you in determining which grade of steel to select. In open pockets of the cutterhead use filler stock.

The black section shows a 90 degree corrugated cutter head. The gray area is a 60 degree corrugated knife. When this 60 degree knife is installed into the 90 degree head body, the knife is not properly locked. The knife is not as stable as it should be. This can cause the loss of accuracy. When attempting to increase the feed rate, this is very important. Under a jointed type production, the knife can vibrate. This will not allow the knives to stay completely tight.

 

When the angle in the cutter head body and on the knife match they will fit properly on the edges. The knife steel should have a slight flat so that the steel is held in place by the edges of the knife not the point of the knife.

- back

 

BALANCE OF TOOLS

The importance of balanced tools can not be overstated. A slight mis-balance of any part of the tool can cause a major vibration. This results in chatter and other finish problems, as well as machine damage such as bearing failure and spindle misalignment.

When balancing the tools, all parts must be checked. The gibs should be balanced as a set. Note: If using dual hook angle heads, keep gibs and pockets matched. The gib screws should be checked. The knives should be balanced.

Use a Harvard Trip Balance as shown below, for easy balance. The scale should be zeroed before each use. Keep the balance in a clean place for storage and in a non-windy place while in use. The use of an electronic scale is also common. It should be noted that when cutting steel a magnetic force can be created. This can cause the scale to misread.

A tool that is improperly balanced will increase cost of operation as well as increase operator frustration.

The rotational force that is put onto the machine spindle is extreme. For example, at 6,000 rpm a single part of the tool being out of balance by 1 gram is equal to a 22 pound bowling ball being spun in a circle over your head. This 1 gram can come from a gib screw, a gib, a knife, a backing plate, the head body or from dust and chips collected during the operation of the tool.

After the tool has been used and the knives are removed from the head body, rebalance them before reinstalling them into the head. It is also suggested that the gibs in the head body be numbered, as well as the knives. This way the knives can be put back into the same pocket of the head body. This will reduce the amount of possible error caused by corrugation differences.

A log book can also be used to record which head body the knives were used in. If a problem such as chatter exist when ever the same cutter is used or when the same head body is used then that part of the tool can be checked for balance.

- back

Do you have a question for the Moulder Dr.?  CLICK HERE